STG Health Services

Anxiety Care

Start a screening

Why Everything You’ve Been Told About “Managing” Anxiety Might Be Making It Worse

TL;DR: The Quick Answer

Anxiety isn’t a bug—it’s your nervous system doing its job. The problem isn’t that you feel anxious; it’s what happens after. Research shows three evidence-based strategies help: (1) build self-regulation through small, specific if-then plans, (2) design your environment to reduce decision fatigue and limit anxiety-triggering inputs, and (3) get regular exposure to nature—even looking at trees helps. The key insight? Stop trying to control your internal experience and start controlling what you actually can: your habits, your environment, and your inputs.

You know that feeling when you’re lying in bed at 2 AM, mentally rehearsing a conversation that might never happen? Or when you’ve read the same email seventeen times because you can’t decide if it sounds “off”? Or when your to-do list feels less like a plan and more like evidence of all the ways you’re falling behind?

Yeah. That’s anxiety doing its thing.

And if you’ve tried all the usual advice—deep breaths, positive thinking, “just relax”—and found yourself feeling worse, not better, I have some news that might actually help:

You’re not bad at managing anxiety. You might just be trying to solve the wrong problem.

The Counterintuitive Truth About Anxiety

Here’s what most self-help gets wrong: they treat anxiety like a bug in your system that needs to be fixed. But anxiety isn’t a malfunction. It’s your nervous system doing exactly what it evolved to do—scanning for threats and preparing you to respond.

The problem isn’t that you feel anxiety. The problem is what happens after you feel it.

Dr. Olivia Remes, a mental health researcher at Cambridge University whose TED talks have been watched by millions, has spent years studying what separates people who get stuck in anxiety spirals from people who bounce back. And the difference isn’t what you’d expect.

It’s not that resilient people feel less anxiety. It’s that they’ve developed a different relationship to it.

Remes and her colleagues studied over 10,000 British women and found that the key factor wasn’t how much stress people faced—it was whether they maintained what researchers call a “sense of coherence.” People with this quality view life as generally comprehensible, manageable, and meaningful, even when things get hard. Among women without this sense of coherence, those living in deprived areas were almost twice as likely to have generalized anxiety disorder compared with those in more affluent areas. But here’s the critical finding: for women with a strong sense of coherence, area deprivation wasn’t significantly associated with anxiety at all.

The good news? This isn’t some mystical trait you’re born with. It’s something you can build.

Three Things That Actually Work (According to Science)

1. Use “If-Then” Plans to Outsmart Your Brain

Key Insight: A meta-analysis of 94 studies with over 8,000 participants found that “implementation intentions”—simple if-then plans—have a medium-to-large effect on goal attainment (d = 0.65). This research has replicated consistently, unlike some older willpower theories.

Okay, stay with me here because this sounds almost too simple.

Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer has spent decades studying why we fail to act on our good intentions. The answer isn’t willpower—it’s specificity. When we make vague plans (“I’ll be less anxious”) or rely on motivation (“I’ll just try harder”), we set ourselves up to fail. But when we create concrete if-then plans that link a specific situation to a specific response, something interesting happens: the behavior becomes more automatic.

Here’s how it works: instead of saying “I’ll check my phone less,” you say “If I feel the urge to check my phone while working, then I’ll take three deep breaths and wait ten minutes.” The if-then format creates a mental link between the situation and your desired response, making the response more likely to happen without requiring you to rely on willpower in the moment.

The research is remarkably robust. Unlike some psychology findings that have struggled in replication attempts, implementation intentions show consistent effects across different contexts—health behaviors, academic performance, anxiety management, and more. The key seems to be that by anticipating obstacles and pre-planning responses, you reduce the cognitive load required to make good decisions when you’re stressed or depleted.

What this means for you: Start with one specific anxiety trigger. Maybe it’s the urge to catastrophize before a meeting, or the impulse to repeatedly check your email. Create an if-then plan: “If I notice myself imagining worst-case scenarios before my 3pm meeting, then I will write down one realistic outcome and one thing I can control.”

The plan doesn’t have to be perfect. It just has to be specific and actually doable. Research shows that implementation intentions are most effective when you’re genuinely motivated by the goal—so pick something that actually matters to you.

2. Design Your Environment Instead of Fighting It

I know, I know. “Limit your news consumption” feels irresponsible. But hear me out.

Your brain can’t tell the difference between a threat on a screen and a threat in your living room. When you watch upsetting news, your nervous system responds as if you’re in actual danger—releasing stress hormones, increasing heart rate, preparing for fight or flight. Do that repeatedly, day after day, and you’re essentially training your nervous system to stay on high alert. Chronically.

Remes’s advice is refreshingly specific: “Only listen to the beginning of the programme, just enough so that you get the gist and the headlines, and then turn it off before they go for the in-depth discussion.”

This isn’t about being uninformed. It’s about being strategic with your limited psychological resources.

The bigger principle: Design your environment so you don’t have to constantly fight against it.

Move your phone to another room when you’re working. Use website blockers. Don’t keep foods in your house that you’re trying not to eat. These aren’t signs of weakness—they’re signs of intelligence. You’re working with your psychology instead of against it.

“When we do things like this, our environment supports us,” Remes explains. “This way, we don’t have to use up all our energies to control what’s going on around us.”

Think of it this way: every decision you don’t have to make is energy you can spend on things that actually matter.

3. Get Outside (Or At Least Look at Trees)

This one has the most dramatic research behind it, and it’s probably the easiest to implement.

A 2024 study from Texas A&M analyzing over 61 million outpatient encounters across 1,169 zip codes found that people living in neighborhoods with adequate green space (what researchers call “Nature Adequate”) had 51% lower rates of depression and 63% lower rates of bipolar disorders compared to those in nature-deficient areas. These are correlational findings—we can’t say green space caused the improvement—but the association is striking and consistent with a large body of research.

And a meta-analysis of 59 studies confirmed that exposure to green spaces is consistently associated with reduced risk of anxiety, depression, and other psychiatric conditions.

But here’s the part that surprised me: you don’t have to go full forest-bathing retreat to get benefits. Research shows that even looking at images of nature—changing your desktop background, putting up pictures of trees—produces measurable stress-reduction effects. A 2025 study found that virtual exposure to natural environments produced significant reductions in anxiety and stress in healthy adults. So if you can’t get outside, digital nature is better than no nature.

That said, Remes encourages the real thing when possible: “Go outside, collect leaves and rocks, feel the smooth texture of a leaf crinkling in your hand. It’s an important contrast to our daily lives, where everything we touch is manufactured by humans.”

Her specific recommendation? “Walk barefoot on grass. Being grounded in this way helps you feel present.”

The science behind it: Nature exposure appears to activate your parasympathetic nervous system—the “rest and digest” system that counteracts your stress response. It’s like a reset button for your overworked threat-detection system.

What About Meditation? (The Non-Cliché Version)

I almost didn’t include this because “try meditation” is such tired advice. But the research is too strong to ignore—and there’s a specific mechanism that makes it relevant to anxiety.

Remes stumbled into it accidentally—she saw a flyer for a meditation class and figured, why not? “I really thought the class was life-changing,” she recalls. “By the end, all the stress I had been feeling had gone away.”

The neuroscience backs her up. Studies show that consistent mindfulness practice literally changes brain structure—increasing cortical thickness in areas related to emotional regulation and reducing reactivity in the amygdala (your brain’s alarm system).

But here’s what the research actually shows about what works: consistency matters more than duration. You don’t need to become a monk. You just need to show up regularly, even if it’s brief.

The mechanism seems to be about building the capacity to notice anxious thoughts without automatically reacting to them. You create a little gap between “I’m having an anxious thought” and “I’m spiraling into an anxiety hole.”

That gap is everything.

The Paradox That Changes Everything

Here’s the thing that ties all of this together:

The more you try to control your anxiety, the worse it often gets.

Think about it. Telling yourself “stop being anxious” requires you to focus on your anxiety. Suppressing anxious thoughts takes mental effort—which depletes the same resources you need to stay calm. It’s like trying to fall asleep by concentrating really hard on falling asleep.

The three strategies above work precisely because they sidestep this trap. They don’t ask you to control your internal experience. They ask you to control what you actually can control:

“When you’re faced with uncontrollable events, all you can do is focus on the things that you can control and let everything else fall to the wayside,” Remes says. “It turns out that when you do that, you become happier and you start to feel like you’re in charge of your life.”

When to Seek Professional Help

Everything in this article is backed by solid research, but I want to be honest about the limits:

These strategies are not replacements for professional help.

If your anxiety is significantly interfering with your work, relationships, or daily life—or if you’re experiencing panic attacks, using substances to cope, or having thoughts of self-harm—please talk to a mental health professional. Cognitive-behavioral therapy, particularly exposure-based approaches, remains the gold standard for anxiety disorders, with strong evidence for effectiveness.

The strategies here can complement professional treatment beautifully. But they shouldn’t delay it if you need it.

If you’re in Canada and need support:

The Bottom Line

Anxiety isn’t something you beat. It’s something you learn to carry differently.

The people who navigate it successfully aren’t the ones who figured out how to never feel anxious. They’re the ones who built the capacity to feel anxiety and keep moving anyway—who developed habits and environments that support their wellbeing instead of undermining it.

That’s not a personality trait. It’s a skill. And skills can be learned.

Start small. Be patient with yourself. And remember: the goal isn’t to feel nothing. It’s to feel everything and still be okay.

You can do this.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why doesn’t “just relax” work for anxiety?

Telling yourself to relax requires focusing on your anxiety, which paradoxically amplifies it. More effective approaches involve changing your environment, creating specific action plans, or engaging with nature—strategies that work indirectly rather than trying to directly control your internal state.

How long does it take to see results from these strategies?

Nature exposure can produce measurable stress reduction effects almost immediately. If-then plans show effects within days to weeks as you build the habit. Meditation typically requires consistent practice over weeks to months to produce lasting changes in brain structure and emotional regulation capacity.

What if I can’t get outside regularly?

Research shows that even virtual nature exposure—images, videos, or VR—produces significant stress-reduction effects. Change your desktop background to nature scenes, put up pictures of trees or landscapes, or watch nature documentaries. While real nature exposure is ideal, digital alternatives are better than nothing.

Is anxiety always bad?

No. Anxiety is your nervous system’s threat-detection system doing its job. Moderate anxiety can improve performance, increase attention to important details, and motivate preparation. The goal isn’t to eliminate anxiety but to develop a healthier relationship with it so it doesn’t spiral into chronic distress.

What’s the difference between normal anxiety and an anxiety disorder?

Anxiety disorders involve anxiety that is disproportionate to actual threats, persists over time, and significantly interferes with daily functioning. If anxiety is preventing you from working, maintaining relationships, or doing normal daily activities—or if you’re experiencing panic attacks or using substances to cope—it’s worth talking to a mental health professional.

Research References

Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69-119.

Makram, O. M., et al. (2024). Nature and Mental Health in Urban Texas: A NatureScore-Based Study. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 21(2), 168.

Remes, O., et al. (2018). A strong sense of coherence associated with reduced risk of anxiety disorder among women in disadvantaged circumstances: British population study. BMJ Open, 8(4), e018501.